Monday, November 28, 2011

Five newspapers, five paragraphs -- one good story

What follows are the five opening paragraphs yesterday to five newspapers' Thanksgiving weekend holiday shopping stories. Which one do you like best?

1. Drawn by heavy promotions and earlier-than-ever opening times, shoppers swarmed the malls on Black Friday weekend and handed retailers a good start to the holiday season.

2. Spurred by aggressive promotions from retailers, American consumers opened their wallets over the holiday weekend in a way they had not since before the recession, setting records in sales and traffic.

3. Retail sales broke records during the Thanksgiving weekend, giving a needed boost to a long-suffering economy and raising retailers' hopes for the best holiday shopping season ever.

4. Retailers were cheered that their mix of deep discounts, early openings and website investment produced a strong start to the holiday season. Now, they're plotting more price cuts to keep wary consumers interested for the rest of the key retailing period.

5. Shoppers lured by deep discounts and early store openings sent sales over the four days starting on Thanksgiving soaring 16.7% over the same period a year ago to $52.4 billion, according to the National Retail Federation.

(Identities of the papers are revealed in the first comment, below.)

Which opening paragraph do you like best? Please post your replies in the comments section, below. To e-mail confidentially, write jimhopkins[at]gmail[dot-com]; see Tipsters Anonymous Policy in the rail, upper right.

21 comments:

  1. No. 5 won for me hands down. Numbers and compelling words and being succinct do it for me. What a great idea to conduct this survey!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Number 2, nice summation to the weekend sales and its impact

    ReplyDelete
  3. Number 1 was my favorite. Number 4 was my least favorite. I thought it was clunky.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The best depends on the market you're trying to reach. General population? No. 2 is my favorite. No. 1 limits sales figures to malls only. Nos. 3 and 4 are bulky and obviously geared toward more financial savvy readers.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree with 2:20 — I liked the numerical facts and tight writing.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I am a skeptic when it comes to numbers that can't be independently verified. These early projections of sales seldom hold up when the real numbers come in several weeks later. Retailers always say things are rosy. I saw a quote from one shopper who noted that there were more parking spots this year. That is a red flag. When you read past Black Friday stories they were all optimistic and upbeat.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This was the one I liked:

    "Retailers, especially those that advertise regularly in Gannett newspapers, posted their best Black Friday sales in history, and store owners gave credit to Gannett's new policy of granting favorable editorial coverage to stores that buy ads."

    ReplyDelete
  8. I picked #5 as my fave first, for the same reasons as 2:20 and 9:56. My second choice was #4 though, because the mention of plans for further price cuts piqued my interest. I want to know how low prices could potentially go so I definitely would've kept reading.

    ReplyDelete
  9. The Black Friday numbers have no meaning until the holiday season is over and a tally is conducted. It is possible that the sales from Black Friday are up, but they are cannibalizing sales later in the Christmas season. If money is tight, people need to take advantage of the discounts. ShopperTrac appears to be a pretty reliable as an indicator but predicting how a holiday season will shake out is pure speculation at this point.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I, too, am skeptical of the "Rah-Rah numbers." I walked right into a Fry's Electronics store last Saturday, picked up my purchases, stood in a very short line and walked out. I asked the clerk why there were no lines? He said its been like this since yesterday (Black Friday.) The parking lot was full, but it didn't appear people were buying.

    ReplyDelete
  11. The National Retail Association always hypes Black Friday, and then come January, the actual numbers show overall spending to be flat or down since the 2008 crash. Also, Cyber Monday made sense 10 years ago, when most people had high speed internet connections only at work. Now, most have cable or Fios or something similar at home. So that's another bogus story being spoonfed to shortstaffed newsrooms. My job is in danger, and too many of my newspaper friends remain out of work. No one is being a grinch, but everyone is on an extremely tight budget. I'm making a donation to my local foodbank this month instead of getting a gift for myself.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Gee- Nobody picked Number 3. Hmmmmmm

    ReplyDelete
  13. You are correct, 12:41. No. 3 is full of sad old cliches and tells me nothing.

    "needed boost," "long-suffering economy," "the best holiday shopping season EVER?"

    Pppppfffffftttttt. I wouldn't get past the first graf.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Before I read what the comments are, I will pick number 2 as my favorite.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Probably the most analytical of all the Black Friday stories, and from a non-traditional outlet.

    http://finance.yahoo.com/blogs/daniel-gross/black-friday-boom-masks-physical-retailers-desperation-125410165.html

    ReplyDelete
  16. No. 2 was the most visual lede. It pulled me right in. Numbers can wait a graf or two.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Clear winner to me -- No. 2.

    ReplyDelete
  18. No.3 was rewritten by an editor who thought he knows better.no kidding.

    ReplyDelete
  19. 1:08 is correct. Another sign that Money editors are out of touch. Rewriting cliches with he journalism of hopes naive and inappropriate. As others have commented here, Thanksgiving means nothing in aggregate holiday sales.

    Lets hope the next holiday sales story is a bit more sophisticated and analytical.

    ReplyDelete

Jim says: "Proceed with caution; this is a free-for-all comment zone. I try to correct or clarify incorrect information. But I can't catch everything. Please keep your posts focused on Gannett and media-related subjects. Note that I occasionally review comments in advance, to reject inappropriate ones. And I ignore hostile posters, and recommend you do, too."

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.